Best Italian Restaurants in Kingston

Kingston's Italian dining scene is a delightful surprise that blends authentic flavors with Caribbean warmth. From family-run trattorias serving handmade pasta to innovative pizzerias putting creative spins on classic recipes, the city has quietly developed one of the Caribbean's most impressive collections of Italian restaurants. What sets Kingston apart is how these establishments have maintained their Italian soul while embracing the local culture - you'll find the same passionate attention to quality ingredients and traditional techniques, but with a uniquely Jamaican sense of hospitality that makes every meal feel like a celebration.

This guide showcases the cream of the crop: 10 exceptional Italian restaurants that have earned their stellar reputations through consistently outstanding food and service. Each spot featured here has ratings of 4.5 stars or higher, with an impressive collective average of 4.6 stars from thousands of satisfied diners. Whether you're craving a perfectly charred Neapolitan pizza, silky homemade gnocchi, or a romantic dinner with wine pairings, these handpicked establishments represent the very best Italian dining experiences Kingston has to offer. Prepare to discover your new favorite Italian hideaway.

Featured Restaurants

$$

Savona's Trattoria & Bar - Kingston

★★★★☆

4.5

(1,208 reviews)

This beloved Kingston institution combines the warmth of an Italian trattoria with the relaxed vibe of a neighborhood bar, creating an inviting atmosphere that keeps locals and visitors coming back. With an impressive 4.5-star rating from over 1,200 reviews, Savona's has clearly mastered the art of consistent quality and hospitality that travelers appreciate. Make reservations ahead of time, especially on weekends, as this popular Broadway spot tends to fill up quickly with both tourists exploring historic Kingston and devoted regulars.

11 Broadway, Kingston, NY 12401, USA

View Map Website

$$

Frank Guido's Little Italy

★★★★☆

4.6

(1,137 reviews)

Frank Guido's Little Italy brings authentic Italian-American charm to Kingston's historic downtown, where generous portions and classic comfort food have earned a devoted local following. With over 1,100 glowing reviews and a stellar 4.6-star rating, diners consistently praise the warm family atmosphere and consistently satisfying meals that feel like dining at an Italian grandmother's table. Arrive early on weekends to snag a table at this beloved neighborhood gem that locals have clearly embraced as their go-to spot for hearty, no-fuss Italian fare.

14 Thomas St, Kingston, NY 12401, USA

View Map Website

$$

Pizza Please Liguanea

★★★★☆

4.9

(812 reviews)

Pizza Please Liguanea has earned a stellar reputation among locals and visitors alike, with nearly 5-star ratings from over 800 diners who rave about the consistently delicious food and welcoming atmosphere at this popular Liguanea Plaza spot. The restaurant's diverse menu and reliable quality have made it a go-to destination for satisfying meals in a convenient shopping plaza setting. Arrive early during peak dinner hours to snag a table, as this beloved eatery tends to fill up quickly with regulars who know they're in for a treat.

Shop 16, Liguanea Plaza, 134 Old Hope Road, Kingston, Jamaica

View Map Website

$$$

Casa Domenico

★★★★☆

4.5

(842 reviews)

Casa Domenico draws food lovers with its diverse menu offerings and consistently excellent execution, earning an impressive 4.5-star rating from over 800 satisfied diners. The restaurant's broad culinary approach means there's something to please every palate, making it a reliable choice for groups with varied tastes or travelers seeking quality without the risk. Given its popularity and upscale pricing, reservations are likely wise, especially for dinner service when this Kingston gem tends to fill up with both locals and visitors.

35 Brock St, Kingston, ON K7L 3B5, Canada

View Map Website

$$

Pizza Please Victoria Pier

★★★★★

5.0

(664 reviews)

Pizza Please Victoria Pier delivers exceptional waterfront dining with diverse cuisine options that have earned rave reviews from over 660 satisfied diners. The impressive pier location combined with consistently high-quality food makes it a standout choice for both locals and travelers seeking a memorable meal with scenic views. Visit during sunset hours to fully appreciate the picturesque setting while enjoying their popular dishes at surprisingly reasonable prices.

Victoria Pier, Kingston, Jamaica

View Map Website

$$

GO Italian Restaurant

★★★★☆

4.5

(736 reviews)

Despite its name suggesting Italian fare, GO Restaurant serves up an eclectic mix of cuisines that has earned it an impressive 4.5-star rating from over 700 diners who appreciate its diverse menu options. The generous portion of positive reviews speaks to consistent quality and service that keeps both locals and visitors coming back. With its mid-range pricing and prime Princess Street location, it's perfect for travelers seeking a reliable dinner spot without breaking the bank.

2815 Princess St, Kingston, ON K7P 2X2, Canada

View Map Website

$$

Peppe Restaurant Kingston

★★★★☆

4.5

(687 reviews)

Peppe Restaurant Kingston has earned a stellar reputation among locals and visitors alike, with nearly 700 reviewers praising its welcoming atmosphere and quality food offerings. This popular Kingston spot combines the comfort of a neighborhood bar with reliable meal delivery service, making it a versatile choice whether you're dining in or staying put. Book ahead or arrive early, as the consistently high ratings suggest this gem fills up quickly, especially during peak dining hours.

174 Tudor Dr, Kingston upon Thames KT2 5QG, UK

View Map Website

Culinary Experiences in Kingston

Discover food tours, cooking classes, and unique dining experiences